Brain Images of Normal Subjects





Development of Human Brain Image Banks and Age-Specific Normative Brain Atlases

Programme

Thursday 28th August 2014

8.30

Arrival and registration

9.00

Welcome and introduction (Joanna Wardlaw):

Background to the process, aims and objectives of meeting, meeting format and deliverables

9.10-10.30

Current and ‘emerging’ brain image banks and atlases: Chair: Paul Matthews

5 minute presentations: population/sample covered, structure and main uses of bank/atlas, main challenges and how these have been overcome, future opportunities or challenges for brain image banking

9.10-10.10
Group Speaker
MNI Alan Evans
ADNI Paul Thompson
GIN Bernard Mazoyer
INCF/IMAGEN Jean-Baptiste Poline
OASIS Dan Marcus
BRAINS Susan Shenkin
EPI2: Rotterdam/Leiden Aad van der Lugt
Rhineland Monique Breteler
UK Dementia Platform Claire MacKay
Neonatal banks James Boardman
10.10-10.30 Questions and discussion (Chair: Paul Matthews)

10.30-12.00

Philosophical and statistical problems: ‘What is normal, what is needed to define normal, across the lifespan” Chair: Klaus Ebmeier

10.30-10.40

10 minute summary, highlighting major unresolved questions in brain imaging across the lifespan - Alan Evans

10.40-10.45 Move to discussion groups (Coffee/tea available)
10.45-11.25

Discussion Topics:

  1. What minimum image and metadata, and how much, are needed to define normality? (Chair: John Ashburner)
  2. What can be done with existing/being acquired data to determine normality across the lifespan; what are likely gaps? (Chair: Monique Breteler)
  3. Is it realistic to combine, in one image bank, image data from all stages of life? (Chair: James Boardman + Dominic Job)
11.25-11.30 Move back to plenary group
11.30-12.00 3 minute feedback from each group, and 7 minute discussion per topic (Moderator: Klaus Ebmeier)
12.00-13.00 Lunch, continue discussion
13.00-14.30 Legal and ethical issues Chair: Steve Lawrie
13.00-13.10 10 minute summary highlighting major issues for brain image banking – Graeme Laurie
13.10-13.15 Move to discussion groups
13.15.13.55

Discussion Topics:

  1. Consent, including for secondary uses, mental capacity, ‘selling data’, links with healthcare/industry, between country differences (Chair: Burkhard Schaefer)
  2. Privacy, including anonymisation of image and metadata, levels of access to image data, (Chair: Hester Ward)
  3. ‘Research tourism’, dealing with incidental findings or that develop clinical implications in future, longitudinal studies (Chair: Alison Murray)
13.55-14.00 Move back to plenary group
14.00-14.30 3 minute feedback from each group, and 7 minute discussion per topic (Moderator: Steve Lawrie)
14.30-16.00 Technological issues 1 – Multisource ‘big’ data Chair: Thomas Nichol
14.30-14.40 10 minute summary highlighting major problems for image and metadata variation and infrastructures – “What do we need to use shared data” JB Poline
14.40-14.45 Move to discussion groups (Tea/coffee available)
14.45-15.25

Discussion Topics:

  1. Harmonising core minimum image data and subject meta-data, definitions and variables (Chair: Aziz Sheik)
  2. Database infrastructure, key functionalities, attributes of existing methods, identifiable gaps in functionality? (Chair: Dan Marcus)
  3. Submitting new data; quality assurance, data provenance, processing data/segmentation, avoiding duplication of subjects (Chair: Albert Burger)
15.25-15.30 Move back to plenary group
15.30-16.00 3 minute feedback from each group, and 7 minute discussion per topic (Moderator: Thomas Nichol)
16.15-17.00

Keynote lecture. Paul Thompson “Brain image banks: essential international research infrastructures for the 21st Century”

17.00-19.00 Drinks reception at RSE

Friday 29th August

09.00-10.30 Technological issues 2 – Making image databanks work Chair: Linda Lanyon
09.00-09.10 10 minute summary highlighting major problems for image analysis and atlas creation – Steve Smith
09.10-09.15 Move to discussion groups
09.15-09.55

Discussion Topics:

  1. Atlas creation tools and registration issues – dealing with brain variability (Chair: Bernard Mazoyer)
  2. Outputs: data sharing/citation/storage, how to share individuals’ and study data securely, prevent multiple uses of same image from different sites (Chair: Steve Pavis + David Wyper)
  3. User interface: What functions are required? How is it best delivered? How to prevent unwanted use (eg trying to recreate original data); Different uses for research, clinicians, industry (Chair: Nick Fox)
09.55-10.00 Move back to plenary group
10.00-10.30 3 minute feedback from each group, and 7 minute discussion per topic (Moderator: Linda Lanyon)
10.30-11.00 Coffee
11.00-12.30 Discussion, summary and forward planning
12.30 Lunch
13.30 Close of meeting